Shield to Screen: Ranking Every Captain America Movie Ever Made

Every Captain America Movie Ranked: From Worst to Best

The Shield's Legacy: Ranking Every Captain America Film

The journey of Captain America on the big screen has been a wild ride, from low-budget TV movies in the '70s to some of the greatest superhero films ever made. With Sam Wilson stepping into the role and Brave New World on the horizon, it’s the perfect time to look back and rank every Captain America movie. From laughable misfires to MCU masterpieces, here’s the definitive ranking of every film where Cap throws his mighty shield.

8. Captain America (1979) – A Super Soldier Misfire

The first attempt to bring Captain America to live-action in 1979 was, well… a disaster. Instead of the brave, selfless World War II hero fans knew and loved, this version of Steve Rogers was a mild-mannered artist who had zero interest in becoming a hero. He preferred painting over fighting and only reluctantly took on the role of Captain America. His weapon of choice? A clear plastic shield that looked like a cheap frisbee. His mode of transportation? A goofy motorcycle with a matching shield mounted on the front. The film completely missed the essence of the character, and its sluggish pacing, wooden dialogue, and cheap production values made it almost unbearable to watch. The action sequences were painfully slow, with fight choreography that felt like it belonged in a bad high school play. While some old-school fans may appreciate it for its retro charm, it’s hard to imagine anyone truly enjoying this version of Cap. It’s less "super soldier" and more "super snoozefest."

7. Captain America II: Death Too Soon (1979) – Slightly Less Awful

After the first TV movie flopped, you’d think the filmmakers would go back to the drawing board. Instead, they doubled down with Captain America II: Death Too Soon, released just months later. While it’s a slight improvement over its predecessor, it still falls flat in almost every way. The film’s one saving grace is the legendary Christopher Lee as the villain, General Miguel, a terrorist with a plan to accelerate aging in his enemies. Sounds promising, right? Unfortunately, even Lee’s presence can’t save this uninspired mess. The action is still clunky, the script is as dry as sandpaper, and Steve Rogers remains a bland protagonist with zero charisma. While there’s at least a bit more plot movement this time around, the film still suffers from awkward pacing and a general lack of excitement. The Captain America suit? Still horrendous. At least this movie had the decency to be a little more entertaining, but it’s still firmly in the "bad" category.

6. Captain America (1990) – A Cheap, Campy Disaster

If you ever wanted to see Captain America done on a shoestring budget with some of the worst costume and makeup choices in superhero film history, Captain America (1990) is for you. This adaptation at least attempted to stay somewhat true to the comics, giving Steve Rogers a proper World War II backstory and pitting him against Red Skull. However, that’s where the positives end. This version of Red Skull—bizarrely reimagined as an Italian fascist instead of a Nazi—might be one of the most unintentionally hilarious villains ever. The film is riddled with absurd moments, like Captain America repeatedly faking sickness to steal people’s cars. Seriously, he does it twice. The fight scenes are laughably bad, and the editing is so choppy that it feels like entire chunks of the movie are missing. The costume? It looks like it was made out of cheap rubber, complete with fake plastic ears glued onto the mask. It’s an absolute mess—but at least it’s an entertaining one.

5. Captain America (1944 Serial) – The OG Cap in a Different Form

Long before the Marvel Cinematic Universe, before Chris Evans, before even Marvel Comics was Marvel, there was the 1944 Captain America serial. Instead of Steve Rogers, this version of Captain America follows Grant Gardner, a district attorney who dons the suit to fight crime. The film has absolutely nothing to do with Cap’s comic book origins—there’s no super-soldier serum, no shield, and no Nazi-fighting. Instead, it plays out like a generic crime serial, with Cap going up against a villain named The Scarab, who has created a terrifying superweapon called… The Vibrator. Yes, really. Despite this bizarre departure from the source material, the action is surprisingly solid for a 1940s production, with practical stunts that hold up better than you’d expect. However, at nearly four and a half hours long, the serial is a marathon to sit through. While it’s a fascinating piece of superhero history, it feels more like a curiosity than an essential Captain America film.

4. Captain America: Brave New World (2024) – A Shaky New Beginning

The latest Captain America film, Brave New World, marks a major shift in the franchise, with Sam Wilson officially taking over the mantle. While it successfully sets up a new era, the film struggles with a messy plot, inconsistent pacing, and action sequences that feel over-edited. There are some standout moments, including Harrison Ford’s committed performance as Thaddeus "Thunderbolt" Ross and the long-awaited introduction of Red Hulk. However, Sam Wilson’s Captain America doesn’t get enough strong character development, and the film tries too hard to mimic The Winter Soldier without the same level of depth or intrigue. While it introduces interesting ideas and pushes the MCU forward, it never quite reaches the heights of previous Cap films. That said, it’s far from the worst Captain America movie—it’s just disappointing compared to its predecessors. Hopefully, future installments will refine Sam’s journey and deliver a stronger Captain America film that lives up to his legacy.

3. Captain America: The First Avenger (2011) – A Solid Start

Chris Evans’ debut as Captain America was exactly what the character needed: a heartfelt, nostalgic adventure that embraced his World War II origins while laying the groundwork for the modern-day MCU. The film balances humor, action, and emotion beautifully, giving us a Steve Rogers who is both noble and relatable. Evans nails the role, showing us a hero defined not by his strength, but by his unbreakable moral code. While the film does rush through some parts—especially Steve’s wartime missions, which are mostly shown in a montage—it does a great job of setting up Cap’s arc in future films. Red Skull, played by Hugo Weaving, is a solid, if slightly underdeveloped, villain. The film’s heartfelt ending, with Steve sacrificing himself and waking up in the modern world, is one of the MCU’s most memorable moments. It’s a great introduction to Cap and a strong standalone film, even if it’s overshadowed by what comes next.

2. Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014) – The MCU's Political Thriller

If The First Avenger introduced Steve Rogers, The Winter Soldier redefined him. Ditching the classic superhero formula, the Russo Brothers turned this sequel into a gripping political thriller. With HYDRA revealed to have infiltrated S.H.I.E.L.D., Steve is forced to question everything he stands for. The action is some of the best in the entire MCU, with tight, brutal hand-to-hand combat that feels refreshingly grounded. The highway fight and elevator brawl are legendary. Meanwhile, Bucky Barnes’ transformation into the Winter Soldier gives the film an emotional core, as Steve fights not just a faceless villain, but his long-lost best friend. With gripping suspense, fantastic performances, and deep political intrigue, The Winter Soldier elevated Captain America from a traditional hero to one of the MCU’s most compelling characters. It’s still one of the best Marvel movies ever made.

1. Captain America: Civil War (2016) – The Ultimate Showdown

Some argue that Civil War is more of an Avengers film than a Captain America film, but at its core, it’s a deeply personal story about Steve Rogers and his unwavering loyalty to Bucky Barnes. The film delivers one of the MCU’s best conflicts, pitting Cap against Iron Man in a battle that feels earned. Instead of the typical "good vs. evil" setup, both sides have valid perspectives, making the rift between heroes all the more heartbreaking. Zemo, while not the flashiest villain, is one of the most effective, manipulating the Avengers into tearing themselves apart. The film also introduces Black Panther and Spider-Man into the MCU in spectacular fashion, and the airport battle remains one of the franchise’s most iconic scenes. But it’s the emotional final fight between Cap and Tony that cements this as the best Captain America movie—it’s thrilling, tragic, and completely unforgettable.

The Evolution of Captain America

From laughable low-budget attempts to some of the greatest superhero films of all time, Captain America’s cinematic journey is proof of how much the genre has evolved. While not every film is a winner, the character has cemented himself as one of the most iconic figures in pop culture. With Sam Wilson now carrying the shield, the future is wide open—let’s hope Brave New World is just the beginning of a new golden era.

Stay tuned for more deep dives into your favorite superheroes, only at Land of Geek Magazine!

#CaptainAmerica #MCU #MarvelMovies #SuperheroRankings #ChrisEvans