Why Your Favorite Superhero Made Billions—But Not the Creator

How Big Companies Keep Creators Poor: The Dark Side of Comic Book History

Once upon a time, Batman was born—and his co-creator died broke.

That’s not a myth. That’s the comic book industry.

The caped crusader has made over $30 billion, but Bill Finger, the man who helped invent him, passed away in poverty, uncredited for decades. Meanwhile, Joe Shuster, co-creator of Superman, spent his later years working as a janitor, blacklisted from the industry he helped shape.

This isn’t just comic book history—it’s the reality of how big companies have treated creators for generations. And while you'd think that things have gotten better since the Golden Age… the truth is much more complicated.

🦸‍♂️ Superman's Curse: Creators vs. Copyright

It all started with a dream. In 1933, Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, two teenagers, created Superman. By 1938, DC Comics published him in Action Comics #1, and the superhero era officially began. For their contribution—and full rights to Superman—they were paid $130.

That’s right. $130. For a character that built an empire.

At first, Siegel and Shuster were kept on to write more Superman stories. But when DC later created Superboy without crediting them—while Siegel was literally fighting in World War II—the gloves came off. They sued.

They lost.
And were fired.

After a second lawsuit in the '60s also failed, both men ended up broke. By the mid-1970s, Siegel resorted to sending out a scathing press release, accusing Warner Bros. of profiting off Superman while his creators starved. The public outcry worked—DC paid them each a $20,000 annual stipend, with a catch: they had to stop pursuing ownership.

Legal victory? Maybe.
Justice? Not even close.

📜 Copyright Law vs. Comic Reality

Copyright law says that creators own what they make—unless they assign those rights away or create work as “work-for-hire.” Siegel and Shuster assigned Superman to DC. But what if creators didn’t?

That’s what brings us to the termination clause—a legal option to reclaim copyright decades after assigning it. Meant to help creators who underestimated the value of their work, it should’ve been a game-changer. And in 2001, Siegel’s heirs used it to reclaim Superman, finally selling the rights back to DC in a lucrative deal.

But not everyone was so lucky.

👑 The King's Battle: Jack Kirby vs. Marvel

Jack Kirby didn’t create one hero—he co-created dozens: X-Men, Thor, Iron Man, the Fantastic Four. In 2009, his family tried to reclaim his creations using the termination clause.

Marvel sued them.

They argued that Kirby’s work was “work-for-hire”—meaning he never had ownership to reclaim. The courts flipped sides multiple times. Eventually, the case was heading to the Supreme Court—and Marvel blinked. They settled, reportedly for $30–50 million.

A win, yes. But also a dangerous precedent. Marvel now uses that settlement to argue that all comics from that era are work-for-hire, shutting down new claims before they start.

💵 The Fine Print That Broke Creators

The worst part? Sometimes creators didn’t even realize they were signing away their rights.

In the 1970s, Marvel started printing contracts on the back of paychecks. That meant when a writer or artist endorsed the check, they legally signed over the rights. That’s how Steve Gerber, the creator of Howard the Duck, lost control of his character—for $285.

When Gerber tried to sue, Marvel sued back. He needed help raising legal funds—and Jack Kirby came to his aid, co-creating Destroyer Duck, a parody comic, to support the fight.

Even more heartbreaking was Gary Friedrich, co-creator of Ghost Rider. Not only did he lose his lawsuit—Marvel turned around and sued him for selling Ghost Rider prints at conventions. He died broke, owing thousands.

🕰 The "Watchmen" Trap

Surely it got better in the modern era, right?

Kinda. In the 1980s, DC made headlines by offering creators like Alan Moore better deals. For Watchmen, Moore was promised that if DC stopped publishing the book for a year, the rights would revert to him.

You can guess what happened next. DC never stopped printing it. To this day, Moore has never received the rights back.

It was a legally clever move, but to Moore, it felt like a betrayal—and he cut ties with the company forever. Watchmen still sells. Moore sees none of it.

🎬 The Marvel Movie Payday (Or Lack Of One)

Let’s talk Marvel movies.

Winter Soldier is a billion-dollar brand. But when the movie premiered in 2014, creators like Ed Brubaker, who redefined the character, weren’t invited. Brubaker said he made more money from his cameo appearance than from creating the Winter Soldier himself.

Reportedly, Marvel gives creators a $5,000 “thank you” check when a character they helped create appears in a film. But that amount is optional, not guaranteed—and the company decides if your contribution is “original” enough to qualify.

So, Jerry Conway (who created Power Girl) was denied royalties because DC claimed she was a “derivative” of Superman. The same loophole lets companies withhold fair compensation on a technicality.

🧠 Why This Keeps Happening

This isn’t just a history lesson. It’s still happening.

The shared universe model makes it harder to track who created what. Comics are collaborative, yes—but the system is set up to favor corporations, not creators. The second a hero joins a larger world, their ownership becomes blurry, and their creator’s claim to value becomes “complicated.”

Publishers exploit this gray area. They always have.

And even today, legal threats, financial risk, and NDAs keep creators quiet. Most creators just want to work—they don’t want to be blacklisted for asking for more.

💔 The Real Cost of Making Superheroes

We love these stories. We dress up like them. Watch them in theaters. Cry when they die. Cheer when they return.

But behind every cape, shield, and mask is a creator—often one who got a fraction of what they deserved.

We’ve come a long way from the days of Bob Kane stealing the spotlight from Bill Finger. But we’re not there yet.

Until Marvel and DC (and others) find a way to fairly compensate creators for work that becomes worth billions, this cycle will keep repeating. Legal technicalities should never outweigh creative humanity.

✊ What You Can Do

Support independent creators. Buy graphic novels from small publishers. And if you’re looking for a way to help directly, consider donating to The Hero Initiative—a nonprofit that helps aging comic creators with medical and living expenses.

It’s a tragic reality that this organization needs to exist. But until things change, it’s one of the best ways to give back to the people who gave us so much.

Stay aware, stay informed, and support creators' rights with more eye-opening deep dives right here at Land of Geek Magazine!

‍#CreatorRights #ComicBookIndustry #MarvelExploitation #DCComics #SupportComicArtists